Fay's Evelyn Bay Coffee Menu

Introducing Fay's Evelyn Bay Coffee, a charming coffee shop nestled in the heart of Charlotte, MI, at 134 S Cochran Rd. This locally owned gem boasts a welcoming atmosphere perfect for relaxation or social gatherings. Customers rave about their delicious offerings, from refreshing iced coffees like the Almond Joy to delectable paninis paired with tasty sides.

Highlighting local pride, their ice cream comes from the renowned Moo-Ville, enhancing the delightful menu that includes a tempting coffee flight—an excellent way to explore various flavors, including the surprising favorite, Viennese mocha.

With multiple seating options, including cozy couches and spacious communal tables, you can easily unwind or engage in lively conversation. Fay's Evelyn Bay Coffee is truly a haven where great food, strong brews, and a community spirit blend seamlessly, inviting you to stay longer and enjoy every moment.